—
## The Broader Pattern of NAGPRA Implementation
The Kennewick case was exceptional in its length, its legal complexity, and its scientific prominence. But it was not unique in its underlying dynamics.
NAGPRA’s implementation since 1990 has involved thousands of cases, most of them resolved without litigation and many without significant public attention. Museums and federal agencies have transferred millions of objects and tens of thousands of sets of remains to tribes across the country. For the most part, this process has worked as intended.
But cases involving very ancient remains — those from before roughly 5,000 years ago — have been disproportionately contentious. The Kennewick case was the most prominent, but there were others. In each case, the same tension arose: tribes asserting continuous ancestral connection based on oral tradition and long residence, and scientists arguing that the evidence for connection was insufficient to establish the kind of cultural affiliation the law required.
The underlying issue was never really about Kennewick Man specifically. It was about a structural gap in NAGPRA’s design — the absence of clear guidance on how to handle remains that predated the traceable history of any present tribal culture. Different federal agencies addressed this gap differently. The Army Corps of Engineers had been willing to apply NAGPRA broadly in the initial Kennewick determination, based on geography and age. The courts, in their 2002 and 2004 rulings, applied a narrower standard that required more specific evidence of affiliation.
The 2016 legislative fix for the Ancient One was not a general solution to the gap. It was a case-specific resolution of a specific dispute. The gap in NAGPRA remains. Future cases involving ancient remains are likely to encounter it again.
