—
## What the Case Did Not Change
The Kennewick case ended with the return and reburial of the Ancient One. But it did not, by itself, change the structural conditions that had made the case so prolonged and contentious.
NAGPRA remains in effect and largely unchanged in its core provisions regarding ancient remains. The gap in the law — the uncertainty about how to apply it to remains so old that standard affiliation evidence is unavailable — has not been legislatively addressed in a general way. Future cases involving very ancient remains will encounter the same ambiguities.
The relationship between scientific institutions and Native American communities has changed, partly as a result of the Kennewick case and of broader cultural shifts in how repatriation and research ethics are understood. Many institutions have adopted more collaborative approaches to ancient DNA research, seeking tribal consent and involvement rather than treating remains as specimens to be studied without reference to community interests. But these changes are practices, not laws, and they are not uniform across the field.
The question of how skull morphology should be used in questions of population affinity — and how morphological findings should be weighted against genetic evidence when the two conflict — has been substantially clarified by the Kennewick case and by the broader development of ancient DNA research. But the methodological lessons have not been uniformly absorbed across all relevant fields.
What the case definitively changed was the disposition of one set of ancient human remains. The Ancient One is in the ground. He rested there for 9,000 years before he was found. After twenty years of dispute, he is at rest again.
