A different framework — associated with the tribal position and with the advocates who supported it — holds that human remains are persons, not evidence. They belong to their communities. The right of a community to determine the treatment of its ancestral dead is a matter of sovereignty and dignity that does not expire with time. Under this framework, the burden of proof runs in the other direction: the right to study ancient remains must be justified, not simply assumed, and that justification requires the consent of the communities most directly affected.
NAGPRA, in its design, adopted something closer to the second framework — but left enough ambiguity in its application to ancient remains that the first framework was able to reassert itself through litigation.
The resolution of the Kennewick case, through legislation and reburial, did not definitively resolve which framework should govern. But it demonstrated, in a specific and concrete way, that the second framework had enough political and moral force to prevail even after two decades of institutional resistance. The Ancient One is at rest. That outcome was not an accident of genomics or a gift of judicial interpretation. It was the result of twenty years of sustained effort by five tribes who refused to accept that the death of their ancestor gave anyone the right to treat him as a specimen.
—
## A Final Note on the Question the Headline Poses
The headline attached to this article — “An 8,500-Year-Old Skeleton Sparked a Fight Over His Origins. DNA Linked Him to Native Americans.” — is accurate as far as it goes. The DNA did link Kennewick Man to Native Americans. The 2015 study demonstrated, using multiple statistical approaches and comparing his genome to populations around the world, that he was more closely related to modern Native Americans than to any other population.
