—

## The 1998 Riverbank Controversy in Detail

The Army Corps of Engineers’ decision to deposit rock and soil over the Kennewick discovery site in April 1998 was one of the most controversial actions in the case’s history, and it deserves closer examination.

The Corps had a genuine and ongoing obligation to manage erosion on the Columbia River banks within its jurisdiction. The site where Kennewick Man had been found was on a stretch of bank that did face erosion challenges, as most riverbanks in the Columbia system do. The Corps argued that the stabilization work was part of its regular maintenance responsibilities and had been planned independently of the Kennewick litigation.

Critics argued that the timing was suspicious. The stabilization work was conducted while the litigation over access to the remains was ongoing, while there were active discussions about whether further excavation of the site might yield additional evidence relevant to the legal proceedings, and before Congress had finalized legislation that might have restricted such action. Representative Doc Hastings testified before Congress that the Corps had moved precipitously and in a way that served the tribal interests in preventing further scientific work at the site.

The Corps denied that its decision was motivated by the litigation. Without evidence of an explicit instruction to bury the site for litigation-related reasons, it is not possible to characterize the Corps’ motivation with certainty. What is certain is the result: the site was buried, additional excavation became effectively impossible, and whatever additional evidence might have been found in the sediments around the discovery location was sealed under hundreds of tons of rock and soil.

ADVERTISEMENT
Advertisement
Share.