They asked the court to block the transfer to the tribes pending a proper review of the Corps’ decision.

The tribes saw the lawsuit differently. For the Umatilla, the Yakama, the Nez Perce, the Colville, and the Wanapum, the legal proceedings were a continuation of a much longer pattern: scientific and governmental institutions overriding tribal rights, treating Native American ancestral remains as scientific specimens rather than as people deserving burial, and using the machinery of law to delay obligations that should have been immediate. Armand Minthorn said in a statement that the tribes viewed the excavation itself as a desecration. “Our oral histories go back 10,000 years,” he said. “We know this individual is a descendant of ours.”

The legal proceedings moved slowly. In February 1997, Magistrate Judge John Jelderks refused to dismiss the scientists’ suit and ordered the Army Corps to conduct a new and more thorough review of the evidence for cultural affiliation. He raised questions about whether the Corps had acted too quickly and had overlooked relevant information. He did not grant the scientists access to the remains, but he left the door open for that question to be revisited.

—

## The Army Corps and the Riverbank

While the legal proceedings were underway, the Army Corps of Engineers did something that generated lasting controversy: it buried the discovery site.

In April 1998, the Corps deposited approximately 500 tons of rock and several hundred tons of soil on the riverbank where the skeleton had been found. The official rationale was erosion control — the bank needed stabilization, and the Corps argued that it had an independent obligation to manage its land. Critics, including some members of Congress, argued that the Corps was effectively destroying the archaeological context of the site in a way that happened to benefit the tribal position in the ongoing litigation by preventing future excavation.

ADVERTISEMENT
Advertisement
Share.