The absence of Banfield and Gusciora meant that of the original eleven crew members, eight would face trial. O’Keefe had already pleaded guilty and would testify for the prosecution.
—
## The Trial
The trial of the eight remaining Brink’s defendants began on August 6, 1956. The proceeding attracted significant public and press attention — the robbery had been the subject of national coverage for six years, and now its resolution was playing out in a Boston courtroom.
The prosecution’s case rested substantially on O’Keefe’s testimony. As the insider who had planned and executed the robbery alongside the defendants, and as the one member of the crew who had cooperated with investigators, O’Keefe was the witness who could place specific individuals in specific roles on the night of January 17, 1950. No other cooperating witness was available, and the physical evidence from the robbery itself was limited.
O’Keefe’s credibility as a witness was vulnerable to challenge in the ways typical of cooperating witnesses: he was himself a convicted criminal who had committed the crime he was testifying about, and his cooperation carried a benefit — a reduced sentence — that defense attorneys could argue gave him incentive to tailor his testimony. These arguments were made, and the defense used them as effectively as the evidence allowed.
After deliberations, the jury returned guilty verdicts against all eight defendants.
The sentences handed down were the maximum available under Massachusetts law: life in prison for each of the eight convicted crew members.
—
## The Sentences and What Followed
Eight men received life sentences for the Brink’s robbery. The sentences reflected both the scale of the crime — the largest robbery in American history at the time of its commission — and the severity with which the Massachusetts courts responded to a case that had dominated law enforcement attention for six years.
