James Faherty and Thomas Richardson were placed on the list after evading the January 12, 1956 sweep. Their inclusion reflected their status as known and identified suspects who could not immediately be located. The publicity associated with the list meant that their descriptions and photographs were widely circulated.

That they were eventually found in Dorchester — the Boston neighborhood they had grown up in — rather than having fled to another city or another country is consistent with the pattern of the broader case. Boston was their world. They knew its streets, its people, and its geography better than any other place. Leaving it would have meant going somewhere they were unknown, with fewer resources and fewer connections. The choice to stay reflected the same logic that had kept the entire crew in Boston throughout the six years following the robbery: this was their world, and they did not know how to operate effectively outside it.

They were arrested on May 16, 1956 — four months after the initial sweep. The delay between the January arrests and the May captures was not for lack of effort; it reflected the difficulty of finding specific individuals in a dense urban environment where community networks could shelter a fugitive. When they were finally located, it was in a neighborhood where they had always been.

—

## The Trial: What the Prosecution Had to Prove

The trial that began on August 6, 1956 presented the prosecution with both significant advantages and genuine challenges.

The advantages were substantial. O’Keefe had cooperated fully and was prepared to testify as the prosecution’s star witness. His account of the robbery was detailed, specific, and internally consistent. He had been there. He could place each defendant in his role, describe what happened inside the Brink’s building, and account for the financial arrangements that followed. No other witness could offer that kind of comprehensive insider account.

ADVERTISEMENT
Advertisement
Share.