Statutes of limitations for criminal charges set a deadline beyond which the state cannot initiate prosecution. The rationale, as noted earlier, involves concerns about the reliability of evidence that ages, the fairness of defending against old charges, and the public interest in finality. For robbery charges in Massachusetts in 1950, the limitation period was six years.
The crew’s calculation was explicit: if they could get to January 17, 1956 — six years from the date of the robbery — without being indicted, the Massachusetts robbery charges would expire. They could not be prosecuted under state law for the robbery itself. The plan was to hold the money, maintain silence, avoid new arrests, and outlast the clock.
The limitation period created an enormous investigative pressure point for the FBI. The bureau knew the deadline as well as the crew did. The years between 1950 and 1956 were not years in which the FBI was passively waiting for something to break — they were years of active, sustained effort to build a case before time ran out.
The critical qualification is that the federal charges were on a different timeline. The FBI’s jurisdiction in the case rested partly on federal statutes — including federal conspiracy statutes that had different limitation periods. When the state robbery charges expired on January 17, 1956, the federal case did not automatically expire with them. This meant that the arrests on January 12 — five days before the state deadline — preserved the state charges, while the federal charges might have remained viable even after that date.
