The specific interplay between state and federal charges, and the precise legal structure of the indictments handed down in January 1956, are not fully detailed in publicly available accounts. What is documented is that the January 12 arrests were made five days before the state deadline, and that the prosecution that followed resulted in convictions. The legal significance of the specific timing — whether the state charges were the basis for the convictions, or whether federal charges were more important — is a question for legal specialists with access to the trial record.
What the near-miss quality of the timing established, in the public memory of the case, was the drama of a legal clock that the crew almost outlasted. The eleven-day gap between O’Keefe’s first conversation with the FBI on January 6 and the state deadline on January 17 meant that the case was resolved by a margin that could have easily gone the other way. Had O’Keefe waited another two weeks to talk, had the FBI moved more slowly, had any element of the January 6-to-12 sequence gone differently — the state charges would have expired.
—
## What O’Keefe’s Testimony Actually Established
O’Keefe’s testimony was the foundation of the prosecution, and understanding what it actually established — as distinct from what it alleged — requires some care.
O’Keefe was a participant in the robbery. He had been inside the Brink’s building on January 17, 1950. His account of what happened that night was based on direct experience, not hearsay or inference. He could testify to what he personally saw, heard, and did — and by extension, to what others in his immediate vicinity saw, heard, and did.
