One relative, in accounts that emerged as the case received media attention, described seeing the twins “in a cage.”
The specific circumstances of how Jack came to be abandoned in Newark, New Jersey, in July 1965 — and who abandoned him there — were not definitively established by the investigation. The working assumption among investigators and researchers was that Gilbert and Marie Rosenthal had abandoned him. The specific mechanics and the specific timing and the specific decision-making that led to a toddler being left in a stroller outside a shopping area have not been fully documented.
What relatives reported was a strategy of concealment that prevented the disappearances from being reported. The Rosenthals had, according to these accounts, managed the two sides of their extended family in a way that prevented either side from knowing that the twins were missing. They told one side of the family that the twins were with the other side, and vice versa. They removed photographs of the twins from the family album. They actively discouraged relatives from asking about the children. By the time either side of the family might have recognized that neither side had seen the twins, years had passed and both Gilbert and Marie Rosenthal had been able to construct a social reality in which the twins had simply… stopped appearing.
No one reported them missing. No investigation was opened. The two children, Jack and Jill Rosenthal, vanished into two separate fates — one of them becoming, through the FBI’s conditional identification and the Fronczaks’ adoption, Paul Fronczak of Chicago, and the other disappearing into a silence that has not broken in the more than sixty years since.
