The investigators and researchers who have worked on the case have not publicly reached a definitive conclusion about Jill’s fate. The range of possibilities includes: that she was abandoned separately from Jack and in a way that left no traceable record; that she died in the household before or after Jack was abandoned; that she was given to another family in some informal arrangement; or that she survived into adulthood in circumstances that have not yet enabled identification.
The man searching for her has said publicly that he believes she may have been killed or harmed at around the time Jack was abandoned. Investigators have noted that it remains possible she is still alive. Neither conclusion has been established. The case of Jill Rosenthal is listed as an ongoing investigation.
## The Real Paul Fronczak: Kevin Ray Baty
While the man raised as Paul Fronczak was discovering his true identity as Jack Rosenthal, a parallel investigation was asking a different version of the same question: if the man raised as Paul Fronczak was not Paul Fronczak, then where was Paul Fronczak?
The FBI, which had reopened the case after the 2012 DNA results, pursued this question for years using the same genetic genealogy techniques that had identified Jack Rosenthal. The commercial DNA databases were growing rapidly throughout the 2010s, and the volume of data in those databases made genetic genealogy investigations increasingly powerful.
The investigation identified the real Paul Fronczak — the infant who had been carried out of Michael Reese Hospital by a woman posing as a nurse on April 27, 1964 — as Kevin Ray Baty, a man living in rural Michigan.
