The 1964 abduction of Paul Fronczak from Michael Reese Hospital, as a criminal case, remains open and unsolved.
## Three Mysteries, Not One
The story that unfolded from the DNA result of 2012 was, by the time its major elements had been identified, not one mystery but three that were connected by chance and consequence.
The first mystery was the one that had been open since 1964: who took Paul Fronczak from Michael Reese Hospital, and what happened to him? This mystery was partially resolved by 2019, when Kevin Baty was identified as the missing infant. It remained partially unresolved because the kidnapper was never identified.
The second mystery was the one that the man raised as Paul Fronczak was living in the middle of: who was he? This mystery was resolved in 2015, when DNA Detectives identified him as Jack Rosenthal of Atlantic City, New Jersey. The resolution brought with it a third mystery.
The third mystery was the one that the resolution of the second had exposed: what happened to Jill Rosenthal? Jack had been abandoned and found. Jill had simply disappeared. This mystery remained unresolved.
The three mysteries shared a common quality: they all involved children who had been displaced from their true identities in the 1960s, without records and without investigation, in circumstances that pointed to adult behavior that ranged from criminal to catastrophic. The woman who posed as a nurse at Michael Reese Hospital committed a deliberate crime against a family. Gilbert and Marie Rosenthal created conditions in which their children were endangered and then managed the aftermath in a way that prevented investigation for decades. The specific actor who abandoned Jack in Newark — presumably one or both of the Rosenthals — left a bruised toddler in a stroller and walked away.
