The documentary was not the first media treatment of the case. ABC News had covered the DNA revelation in 2013, when it became public, and had followed the subsequent investigation as developments occurred. The case had attracted substantial media attention partly because of its inherent dramatic qualities — the double identity, the two missing children, the decades of unknowing — and partly because it occurred at a moment when genetic genealogy and consumer DNA testing were becoming subjects of broad public interest.

 

The 2021 documentary brought together the threads of the story in a form that allowed viewers to follow the investigation’s arc: from the DNA result that disproved the Fronczak connection, through the two-year genetic genealogy investigation that identified Jack Rosenthal, to the ongoing search for Jill, to the eventual identification of Kevin Baty as the real Paul Fronczak.

 

The film also raised a question that the investigation’s documentary record does not fully answer: what does it mean for a person to discover, in middle age, that the foundational story of their identity was about someone else? The man who had been raised as Paul Fronczak had spent his adult life — a marriage, a child, a career, a network of relationships — as a person whose legal identity was built on a case of mistaken identification. The discovery did not invalidate any of that life. It did not change who he was as a person in any immediate, practical sense. But it fundamentally altered his relationship to the past and to the question of origin that sits at the base of personal identity.

ADVERTISEMENT
Advertisement
Share.