It is an identity problem in the psychological and philosophical sense: the problem of what a person is when the foundational story of who they are turns out to be someone else’s story. The man raised as Paul Fronczak, learning at 48 or 49 that he was actually Jack Rosenthal, did not thereby stop being the person he had become through forty-seven years of living. He had to hold two identities simultaneously: the one he had lived, and the one that the DNA had revealed. The process of integrating those two identities — of becoming the person who is both the man who grew up as Paul in Chicago and the man who was born as Jack in Atlantic City — is not a process that completes in a moment of revelation.

 

It is also an identity problem in the legal and institutional sense: a birth certificate, a Social Security number, a name on a driver’s license all anchor a person to a specific identity in the systems that organize social life. When the DNA result established that the man raised as Paul Fronczak was not Paul Fronczak, it did not immediately resolve the question of what his legal identity should be. He had lived forty-seven years as Paul Fronczak in every legal and institutional sense. The discovery of his birth name as Jack Rosenthal did not automatically alter any of those documents or systems.

 

These three senses of identity problem overlap and reinforce each other in a case that is, at its core, about the fragility of the narrative structures through which people understand who they are and where they came from.

ADVERTISEMENT
Advertisement
Share.