The scale of the response to the kidnapping — the 175,000 postal workers, the 200 police officers, the 600 homes searched — was a measure of how seriously the case was taken at the institutional level. This was the largest manhunt in Chicago’s history to that point, by the description given in contemporaneous accounts. The investment of investigative resources was substantial.
And yet it failed. The woman who had taken Paul Fronczak was not found. The baby was not recovered. The investigation, for all its scale, ran out of productive leads within weeks of the abduction and entered the long, desolate condition of the cold case: a file that is kept open, a family that continues to hope, an investigation that continues to process new leads as they arrive, and a fundamental absence of progress toward resolution.
For Chester and Dora Fronczak, the fifteen months between April 1964 and July 1965 were a period of sustained, unresolved grief and uncertainty. Their son was gone. They did not know if he was alive. They did not know who had taken him or why. They had been given every reasonable assurance that the resources of a major metropolitan police department and the FBI were applied to finding him, and those resources had not found him.
The arrival of the FBI’s conditional identification of Scott McKinley — the toddler found in Newark — as the child they could not rule out as Paul must be understood in this context. They had been waiting for more than a year. The FBI’s statement was not a confident identification; it was a statement of negative possibility, the last remaining lead in a case that had exhausted its other directions. The Fronczaks were offered something that was more than nothing: a child who might be their son, who could not be proven not to be their son, who was the right age and had certain physical characteristics that did not conflict with who Paul might have become.
