Jack Rosenthal was born there on October 27, 1963. He had siblings. His parents — Gilbert and Marie Rosenthal — were alive when he was born and when he and Jill disappeared, and remained alive until they died of cancer in the 1990s.

 

The specific history of the Rosenthal family — before the twins were born, during the period of their disappearance, and in the years after — has been partially reconstructed by the investigators and journalists who examined the case, but it remains incomplete. The relatives who gave accounts of the household’s conditions — the descriptions of abuse, the cage, the babysitter’s visit — were providing retrospective accounts based on their recollections, not contemporaneous documentation.

 

What the accounts converge on is a picture of a household that was, for small children, dangerous. Gilbert’s post-Korean War psychological state, as described by relatives, made him volatile and violent. Marie’s alcoholism, as described by relatives, made her unreliable as a caretaker. The specific combination — a traumatized father with PTSD symptoms and a mother with severe substance dependency — is one that child welfare systems now recognize as a high-risk environment for child abuse and neglect.

 

The specific decision — if it was a decision rather than something more chaotic and opportunistic — to abandon Jack in Newark and to do something different with Jill, while managing the family and social circle’s awareness of the twins’ absence, reflects a level of strategic thinking that is not necessarily inconsistent with the chaotic household the relatives described. Even households in disorder can produce calculated deceptions about specific things.

ADVERTISEMENT
Advertisement
Share.