The technique was developed and refined by genealogists and genetic counselors who recognized the potential of the growing databases, and it was applied initially in cases like Paul Fronczak’s — adoptees and people with unknown origins who wanted to find their biological families — before it was adopted by law enforcement for criminal investigation purposes.
The identification of the Golden State Killer in 2018 brought genetic genealogy to wide public attention as a law enforcement tool, but the technique had been used in cases like Paul Fronczak’s for years before that high-profile case. DNA Detectives and similar volunteer groups had developed the methodology and the analytical skills through years of work on identity cases, and the Fronczak case was one of the significant early demonstrations of the technique’s power.
By identifying Jack Rosenthal as the man raised as Paul Fronczak — without a close relative match, without any prior knowledge of the Rosenthal family, working only from the DNA profile and the genealogical databases — DNA Detectives demonstrated that the technique could resolve identity questions that had been unanswerable by any previous means. The same technique, applied by federal investigators and professional genetic genealogists, eventually identified Kevin Baty as the real Paul Fronczak.
The cases that remain unresolved — Jill Rosenthal’s fate, the identity of the hospital kidnapper — are cases where the specific application of genetic genealogy has not yet produced an identification, either because the relevant individuals are not in the databases or because the available genetic evidence is insufficient to narrow the field to a specific person.
