The subsequent identification of Jack Rosenthal and Kevin Baty — the two correct identities — resolved both sides of the mirror. But the resolution arrived at a cost: Kevin Baty died before he could meet Dora Fronczak in person; Jill Rosenthal has never been found; the kidnapper of 1964 has never been identified; Gilbert and Marie Rosenthal died without facing accountability.

 

The mirror is clearer now. Some of what it showed is gone forever.

 

 

 

## Infant Abductions in Twentieth-Century America

 

The abduction of Paul Joseph Fronczak from Michael Reese Hospital in 1964 was part of a pattern of infant abductions from hospital nurseries that had been occurring in the United States for decades and would continue for decades more. Understanding the Fronczak case in this broader context helps explain both why the abduction was possible and why the institutional response to it took the form it did.

 

Hospital infant abductions — a specific category of crime distinct from family abductions in custody disputes — typically involve a stranger who enters a hospital posing as a medical professional or as a friend of the family, gains access to the infant, and leaves with the child. The perpetrators in such cases have historically been, in the great majority of documented instances, women. The motivations, as reconstructed by investigators and mental health professionals who have studied such cases, tend to involve a desire for a child that the perpetrator cannot or believes she cannot have by other means, combined with a willingness to act on that desire without regard for the infant’s family.

ADVERTISEMENT
Advertisement
Share.