By the 1980s and 1990s, when infant abduction cases attracted sustained FBI research attention, a more detailed picture had emerged. The perpetrators, in the majority of documented cases, were women who had recently lost a pregnancy or been unable to conceive, who had often told family or friends that they were pregnant, and who took an infant to present as the child they had claimed to be expecting. The typical geographic pattern was local or regional — the abductor was often from the same general area as the hospital from which the infant was taken.
Whether the woman who took Paul Fronczak fit this profile is unknown. Her identity has never been established. The FBI investigated the case for more than fifty years without identifying her.
## The Second FBI Investigation
When the DNA test of 2012 established that the man raised as Paul Fronczak was not the biological son of Chester and Dora Fronczak, the FBI reopened its investigation of the original 1964 case. The reopening was not simply an administrative formality; it represented an acknowledgment that the FBI’s conditional 1965 identification had been an error and that the original investigation had been closed on a false premise.
The specific investigative steps the FBI took after the 2012 reopening are not fully documented in the publicly available record. What is known is that the investigation eventually pursued the genetic genealogy path that identified Kevin Baty in 2019. That identification required the kind of investigative work that had not been possible in the 1960s, 1970s, 1980s, or 1990s: working backward from the DNA of the man raised as Paul Fronczak’s biological family, identified through genetic genealogy, to the specific individual — Lorraine Fountain and then Kevin Baty — who represented the actual chain of custody of the missing infant.
