## The Weight of a Name

 

Names carry specific legal, social, and psychological weight that is easy to underestimate until a name is challenged or changed. The man raised as Paul Fronczak was Paul Fronczak in every sense that matters for practical life: on his birth certificate (amended after the adoption), on his school records, on his driver’s license, on his employment documents, on his marriage records, on his children’s birth certificates. Paul Fronczak was the name under which he built his entire adult life.

 

The DNA result of 2012 did not change his name in any of these records. It did not alter any document or strip any credential. What it changed was the story behind the name — the account of how the name came to belong to him and what it meant about his origins.

 

The question of whether and how to integrate the name Jack Rosenthal into his identity is one that he has addressed in interviews. His approach has been to acknowledge both names — to present himself publicly as Paul Fronczak while also acknowledging that his birth name, the name he would have had if the Rosenthals had raised him, was Jack Rosenthal. The name Paul Fronczak has effectively become his name in both senses: the name he uses and the name that belongs to his actual life story, however complicated that story is.

 

This resolution is psychologically coherent and practically sensible, but it raises a question about the man who was actually Paul Fronczak: Kevin Baty. If the name Paul Fronczak belongs to the man raised with that name, what does Kevin Baty’s identification as the biological Paul Fronczak mean for the name? The question is partly semantic, but it reflects a genuine complexity in what an identity is — biological origin, or the life actually lived.

ADVERTISEMENT
Advertisement
Share.