The question of what happened to Jill is the last and most deeply unresolved question in the case. The possibilities the available evidence permits are stark: she died before the age of two, as a result of the conditions in the Rosenthal household or in some other circumstance; she was given to someone, as her brother was, and is living now under a different name without knowledge of her origins; or she was given to someone and has discovered or suspects her origins but has not come forward.

 

If she is alive and in the genetic genealogy databases, the identification should be possible, through the same mechanism that identified her brother. The fact that the identification has not been made — as far as is documented in the publicly available record — suggests either that she is not in the databases, that she is not alive, or that the available genetic evidence is not sufficient to narrow the field to a specific identification.

 

The FBI investigation remains open. The NCMEC involvement continues. The man identified as her twin brother continues to publicly advocate for her identification.

 

What happened to Jill Rosenthal is a question that the case, for all its remarkable sequence of revelations, has not answered.

 

## The 1964 Kidnapper: A Profile Never Completed

 

The specific profile of the woman who entered Michael Reese Hospital on April 27, 1964, and left with Paul Joseph Fronczak has never been established. The witnesses who saw her — nurses, staff, possibly other patients or visitors — provided descriptions that were the basis of a composite sketch in 1964. That sketch, and the descriptions underlying it, represent the available record of her physical appearance at the time.

ADVERTISEMENT
Advertisement
Share.