The third finding — Kevin Baty — was of the same character: an identity revelation through genetic genealogy. Kevin Baty was physically present throughout; he was living his life in Michigan. What was found was the connection between his life and the case — the genetic link that established that the infant taken from Michael Reese Hospital had grown up as Kevin Ray Baty.

 

The finding that has not occurred — Jill Rosenthal — is a compound question: not only where she is, but whether she is alive, what happened to her, and what name she is living under. The finding of Jill, if it occurs, would need to establish all of these things. It may need to establish, instead, the specific facts of what happened to her and when.

 

Each of these findings required different tools and different kinds of knowledge. The first required physical investigation and institutional reporting — a stroller in a public place, a child taken into state care, an FBI investigation looking for a specific missing child. The second and third required genetics — both the science of DNA analysis and the infrastructure of large voluntary genetic databases. The fourth remains in a state of dependence on tools that may not yet have produced a result, or may never produce one.

 

## The Investigation’s Long Arc

 

One of the characteristics of the Paul Fronczak case that separates it from many other cold cases is the sustained institutional engagement it has received over six decades. The case was never fully abandoned — the FBI file remained open, and there were investigators across the decades who continued to process new leads as they arrived.

ADVERTISEMENT
Advertisement
Share.