This is not a trivial fact. If the databases had been smaller — if fewer people had voluntarily submitted their DNA — the genetic genealogy analysis might not have produced an identification. The resolution of the case depended, specifically, on the existence of database entries made by people who had no knowledge of the Fronczak case and no specific intention to assist its investigation. They submitted their DNA to learn about their own ancestry, and the existence of their entries in the database made the identification of Jack Rosenthal and Kevin Baty possible.

 

This dynamic — the resolution of a cold case through the accidental contributions of thousands of people who were doing something else entirely — is specific to the genetic genealogy era. It has no parallel in the investigative history of the previous century. It represents a form of collective, inadvertent civic contribution to criminal and missing persons investigation that has emerged from consumer behavior: people learning about their ancestry, by the tens of millions, have simultaneously and without knowing it created an investigative infrastructure that is resolving cases that had been cold for generations.

 

The implications of this dynamic — for privacy, for the development of investigative practice, for the families of people who remain unidentified — are still being worked through. The Paul Fronczak case is one of the foundational instances of genetic genealogy resolving a decades-old identity question, and it arrived early enough in the development of the field that it helped establish both the technique’s possibilities and its limits.

 

The database that made the case’s resolution possible continues to grow. Names and profiles that are not yet in it may be in it next year, or in five years, or in ten. The name that would allow the identification of the 1964 kidnapper may not be in the database today. It may be in the database before the case reaches its seventieth anniversary.

ADVERTISEMENT
Advertisement
Share.