—

## Alkemade and the Psychology of Extreme Decision-Making

The decision that Nicholas Alkemade made in the rear fuselage of the burning Lancaster DS664 — to exit the aircraft without a parachute rather than remain in the burning aircraft — was made in conditions that were among the most extreme that any human being can face.

The specific character of that decision requires careful treatment. The accounts that describe his reasoning — that he chose to fall rather than burn, that the fall offered a quick death while burning would have been agonizing — are retrospective, attributed to Alkemade in interviews and accounts given after his survival was an established fact. The accuracy of this retrospective account of his reasoning is not verifiable. What can be said is that his behavior was consistent with someone who had made a decision rather than simply panicked: he returned to his turret, rotated it to allow egress, and stepped out deliberately.

This behavioral evidence — a person in extreme circumstances acting with enough coherence to execute a specific sequence of actions — is consistent with the psychological research on decision-making under extreme stress, which shows that trained individuals with relevant experience can maintain functional behavior in conditions that would produce paralysis or panic in untrained people. Alkemade’s training as an RAF airman included procedures for bail-out, emergency egress, and survival after leaving the aircraft. The specific actions he performed were actions he had practiced or at minimum rehearsed mentally.

The specific choice to exit without the parachute — recognizing that the parachute was gone and acting on that recognition — is a different kind of decision. It is a decision that most people in that position would have been unable to make. The psychological barrier to stepping out of an aircraft without a parachute is profound and well-documented in the wartime record; numerous accounts describe crewmen who understood that they had no parachute, or that their parachute was damaged, and who could not bring themselves to exit the aircraft regardless. The choice to jump anyway — accepting certain death by falling as preferable to certain death by burning — required a specific quality of decision-making clarity that is unusual even in extreme circumstances.

ADVERTISEMENT
Advertisement
Share.