The problem is that Alkemade’s survival is a case of one. There is no comparison population of people who fell from 18,000 feet into pine forests with deep snow cover, allowing a statistical analysis of survival rates under those conditions. The most that can be said is that the conditions present in his specific case — the trees, the snow, the angle of impact, possibly the orientation of his unconscious body — were consistent with a survivable deceleration profile, and that this consistency explains what happened without requiring any other explanation.

The broader record of high-altitude parachute-less survival during the Second World War includes a small number of other cases — British and American airmen who fell from damaged or destroyed aircraft and survived, in each case due to specific landing-site characteristics that produced a more gradual deceleration than hard-ground impact would have. Each case is unique in its specific circumstances, and no general principle of “how to survive a parachute-less fall” emerges from their combination. What emerges instead is a recognition that the extreme tail of the distribution of possible outcomes from a parachute-less fall includes survival, that survival has occurred under documented conditions, and that the conditions involve specific physical factors that reduced the deceleration on impact.

The aviation safety implications of these cases were not, in practice, that high-altitude falls without parachutes were manageable. The practical implication was the opposite: that the rarity of survival in such falls underscored the absolute importance of parachute equipment for anyone flying at altitude. The Alkemade case was unusual specifically because it was unusual — because almost everyone who fell from an aircraft without a functioning parachute died, and the exceptional case was exceptional enough to be remarkable and worth documenting.

ADVERTISEMENT
Advertisement
Share.