Rökker by 1998 was 77 years old, living in what had been West Germany. He had survived the war, the defeat, and the postwar process of de-Nazification and reconstruction that had transformed Germany from the Third Reich into the Federal Republic. His service record — 64 confirmed aerial victories, Knight’s Cross with Oak Leaves, service as one of the most effective night fighter pilots in the Nachtjagdgeschwader — was part of the history of the air war rather than any active controversy. The Luftwaffe pilots of the Second World War, unlike their counterparts in the Wehrmacht ground forces and the SS, had largely escaped the most intense postwar scrutiny, in part because their role had been defensive — shooting down bombers — rather than the directly atrocity-linked conduct that defined the worst of the ground war.

What the meeting represented for Cleary and for Rökker is not fully captured by the available sources. These kinds of encounters between veterans of opposing sides have been documented throughout the postwar period, and their emotional and psychological content varies enormously by individual. Some veterans find them healing; some find them complicated; some find them anticlimactic. The visit to the crash site — standing in the landscape where the Lancaster went down, with the man who shot it down — carried a weight of historical coincidence that cannot be quantified.

Alkemade had died eleven years before the meeting occurred. He never had the opportunity that Cleary had to stand at the crash site with the pilot who shot down their aircraft. Whether he would have wanted that opportunity, or whether he had any interest in Rökker’s post-war life, is not established by the available record.

ADVERTISEMENT
Advertisement
Share.