This randomness — the pure geographic accident of where he happened to fall — is what makes the survival philosophically interesting in a way that is different from stories of survival through skill or will. Alkemade did everything within his power, which amounted to stepping out of a burning aircraft. What saved him was outside his power entirely: the specific topography of a hillside in the Sauerland that he had never seen and could not have known was there.

The question this raises — the question that most survival stories either avoid or answer simplistically — is what it means to survive through pure chance. No virtue was rewarded. No skill was applied. No decision made the difference. Geography was the difference, and geography was not consulted. Alkemade had no more claim on survival than the four men who died in DS664, and his survival over their deaths was not a reflection of any quality that he possessed and they lacked.

The RAF airmen who flew the Berlin campaign and did not return are not remembered primarily as individuals; they are remembered in aggregate, as the loss figures that historians cite to characterize the campaign’s cost. The ones who returned are remembered individually only when something happened to make them memorable — a particular act, a particular experience, a particular story. Alkemade’s experience made him memorable. It did not make him more deserving of memory than the men whose aircraft went down without anyone surviving to tell the story.

This is not a counsel of nihilism. It is an observation about what survival stories often require us to suppress: the recognition that survival, in many of the cases we most admire, was not the product of the survivor’s qualities but the product of circumstances the survivor did not control. Alkemade survived, and his survival is worth knowing about, and the specific combination of physics and geography that produced it is genuinely remarkable. What it was not was deserved, in any sense that connects desert to character. It happened, and happening is enough.

ADVERTISEMENT
Advertisement
Share.