This shift was apparent to critics at the time. The Stewart of the Mann westerns was not the Jefferson Smith of *Mr. Smith Goes to Washington*; he was a more complicated figure, capable of obsessive vindictiveness, willing to hurt people, navigating a world that did not resolve into simple moral clarity. The films that Hitchcock made with him — *Rope* (1948), *Rear Window* (1954), *The Man Who Knew Too Much* (1956), *Vertigo* (1958) — pushed this complexity further. *Vertigo* in particular presented a Stewart character so consumed by obsession and control that he becomes the villain of his own story.

 

Whether the war was the direct cause of this shift in his work is a question that historians and film scholars have debated. The counterfactual is unavailable: we cannot know what Stewart’s career would have looked like if he had not enlisted. What can be said is that the man who returned from Europe in 1945 had accumulated experiences that were not available to the man who had gone, and that the films he made afterward reflected a sensibility that engaged with darkness and moral complexity in ways his prewar work had not.

 

—

 

## The Presidential Medal of Freedom

 

In 1985, President Ronald Reagan awarded Stewart the Presidential Medal of Freedom, the highest civilian honor in the United States. The citation covered both his film career and his military service.

 

By 1985, Stewart was seventy-seven years old. His film career was essentially over — he had made his last major film in the 1970s and his last significant screen appearance in *The Magic of Lassie* in 1978. His public presence was limited to occasional appearances and award ceremonies.

ADVERTISEMENT
Advertisement
Share.