The other sources — the biographies, the accounts from crew members, the film scholarship that connects his postwar work to his wartime experience — fill in what the official record cannot contain. Together, the official and unofficial record produces something closer to a full account than either source alone.
—
## The Small Town as Anchor
Stewart returned to Indiana, Pennsylvania throughout his adult life. The hardware store was there; his father was there, then after his father’s death the memory of his father was there. The town maintained its pride in its famous son in the specific, quietly persistent way that small American towns maintain pride in figures who have done something notable.
The Jimmy Stewart Museum opened in Indiana, Pennsylvania in 1995, two years before his death, maintaining memorabilia from his film career and his military service. The museum exists in the same town where the hardware store had been, where the family had been, where J.M. Stewart and Co. had served the community for generations.
The connection between the hardware store owner’s son and the Oscar winner and the bomber pilot is not incidental. Indiana, Pennsylvania was not a place that produced many Academy Award winners or Eighth Air Force command pilots. Stewart was an extraordinary exception from an ordinary background, and the town’s relationship with him — and his relationship with the town — was shaped by the specific character of the place he had come from.
He made no apologies for Indiana, Pennsylvania. He spoke about it warmly when he spoke about it at all. The simplicity that his critics sometimes identified as a limitation — the perception that he was playing the same character, the earnest American, in picture after picture — was connected to the genuine simplicity of his origins in a way that his detractors did not always acknowledge. The earnestness was not a pose; it came from somewhere.
