What the defense account did succeed in doing — in a narrow sense — was providing Lavona with a framework in which she was not the person who entered a hospital ward and took a newborn from beside a sleeping mother. Whether she believed her own account, whether parts of it were accurate and other parts fabricated, whether the mysterious Sylvia was a real person who enabled the crime from the shadows — these questions remain officially unresolved. The court found the evidence against the direct-entry account overwhelming.
Miché Solomon, separately, in her memoir and in interviews, described wanting to hear from Lavona what actually happened on the day she was taken. She wanted an explanation. She said she was still waiting for Lavona to tell her the truth.
—
## The Investigating Officer
Lieutenant Mike Barkhuizen, now retired from the South African Police Service, handled the Zephany Nurse case for years. His account of the final investigation — the discovery at the school, the records check, the DNA process — provides the clearest documented reconstruction of how the case was solved in 2015.
Barkhuizen described the case as a rollercoaster: years of silence, the false hope of the extortion call in 2009, the sustained public search, and then the final weeks in January and February 2015 when the puzzle came together rapidly. He told reporters in 2023, after Lavona Solomon was released on parole, that he believed Solomon had received a lenient sentence and should have served longer. He described the suffering of the Nurse family across seventeen years as immense.
