—

## The Book and Its Reckoning

*Zephany*, published in 2019, was the first full account of the case from Miché’s perspective. She was twenty-two years old when it appeared.

The book was not a straightforward vindication story. Miché did not write about being rescued. She wrote about being upended. The childhood she described was, in her telling, genuine — a stable home, a loving mother, a normal life in Lavender Hill. The revelation of 2015 did not retroactively make that childhood false in her experience. What it did was force her to hold two incompatible truths simultaneously: the woman who raised her had committed a crime against another woman and another family; and that same woman had been, in the daily texture of her life, a devoted parent.

She described seeing Lavona walk to court — head down, covered — and said the sight broke her. She described the people shouting at Lavona and said she could not hate her mother. She wrote that she had forgiven Lavona and that she still visited her regularly while Lavona was in prison.

The book also addressed the relationship with the Nurse family, which the memoir described with frank difficulty. She reportedly called Morne a “lost cause” in its pages — a characterization that caused pain. Celeste, by one account, described herself as heartbroken when she read how Miché had portrayed her. Morne declined to publicly respond to the memoir’s contents.

The relationship between Miché and her biological family was, and remained, a work in progress. The DNA test confirmed biology. It could not manufacture the emotional history that was absent.

ADVERTISEMENT
Advertisement
Share.