Miché, by 2020, was a mother herself, described in one report as having given her biological parents two grandchildren. She had stayed with Celeste and Morne during the COVID-19 lockdown period.

—

## The Groote Schuur Ward in Retrospect

The specifics of how a person could enter a hospital maternity ward, take a newborn from beside a sleeping mother, and leave without being stopped belong to a different era of hospital security. Groote Schuur Hospital in 1997 had no security infrastructure at the ward level sufficient to prevent what happened. There were no cameras that recorded the event. There was no system requiring visitors to sign in or be verified before accessing the ward.

This was not unusual at the time. Maternity wards across South Africa and in many countries worldwide in the 1990s operated with relatively open access, on the assumption that the community of people who visited — family members, friends, nurses, midwives — posed no threat to the infants. The concept of deliberately targeting a maternity ward to take a newborn was not a risk that security infrastructure was designed to prevent.

The discovery of the abandoned pillow in the disused tunnel linking the ward to the outside suggested deliberate preparation: a prop used to simulate pregnancy, carried in through the tunnel, discarded on the way out. Whether this reconstruction is accurate — it is based on inference from the physical evidence found, not on a verified account of events — it implies someone who had thought through the logistics in advance.

The hospital itself became part of the case’s symbolic weight. The place where Zephany was born — the site of the caesarean section, the place where Celeste held her daughter for two days — was also the place where she was taken. The beginning and the crime were the same location.

ADVERTISEMENT
Advertisement
Share.