The genetic explanation for this resemblance is straightforward. The two girls shared both biological parents — Morne and Celeste Nurse. Full siblings typically share approximately fifty percent of their DNA. The phenotypic expression of that shared genetics — the face shape, the coloring, the features that multiple observers independently noticed — was visible enough to generate comment at a school where neither girl was trying to conceal anything.

The selfie that the two girls took — reportedly circulated among friends and among Morne and Celeste — served as a fixed image that allowed Miché’s appearance to be compared directly against Zephany’s age-progressed descriptions. Morne had spent years carrying a mental image of what his daughter would look like at various ages. When the selfie reached him, he recognized something.

The reliability of human facial recognition across a family resemblance is imperfect and variable — people can and do see resemblances that do not exist, and can miss them when they do. But in this case, the resemblance was real, it was noticed by multiple independent observers, and it was confirmed by a question about a birth date and subsequently by DNA.

—

## Seventeen Years as a Number

What does seventeen years actually mean in the life of a family?

Morne Nurse was twenty-one years old when Zephany was taken. He was thirty-eight when she was found. His entire adult life up to that point had been organized, in some dimension, around the search and the loss. The annual birthday appeals, the sustained contact with police, the vigilance — all of it was woven through the years of a young man becoming a middle-aged man.

ADVERTISEMENT
Advertisement
Share.