It works poorly when the child is taken as a newborn, raised lovingly, never aware of the crime that made their childhood possible.
Miché’s question — articulated in the title of an interview she gave in 2019, “What if I didn’t need saving?” — cuts to the core of this complexity. From inside her childhood, she was not a child in need of rescue. She was a child with a family, a home, a mother. The fact that the family was constructed through crime was not part of her conscious experience.
What she lost in the revelation was not just the specific identity she had known. She lost the unquestioned sense that her history was her own. The childhood that she had lived — the memories, the relationships, the daily texture of seventeen years — became, overnight, the evidence of a crime. She herself became, in the eyes of the law and of the media, the victim of a kidnapping. But she had not experienced herself as a victim.
This is not an argument that the crime against her was minor or that the resolution was wrong. The crime against her was real and serious: she was deprived of her biological family, her biological identity, and her right to know the truth of who she was. The resolution — the DNA confirmation, the conviction — was the appropriate legal outcome.
What it means in terms of her emotional experience is more complex. She forgave the woman who took her. She loved her. She still does, by her account. These are not contradictions of the crime’s reality. They are testimony to what a child’s love for a parent is — capable of persisting even when the relationship is built on something terrible.
