Miché has said she wants to understand what happened. She has said she forgives. She has not said the crime was excusable. These are compatible positions: forgiveness for the person does not require judgment that the act was anything other than what it was.

The court, the police, and the families of missing children in South Africa who have watched this case unfold have largely held that the sentence was insufficient for the gravity of the offense. The seventeen-year impact on the Nurse family — the divorce, the sustained grief, the annual public appeals, the loss of Zephany’s childhood and adolescence from their lives — represents a harm that extends beyond any sentence that Lavona Solomon served.

Miché’s relationship with Lavona continues, by her account, to be one of love complicated by the knowledge of what that love cost another family. That complication is not one she can resolve by choosing sides. She was raised in love. The love was real. The crime was also real. The simultaneous truth of both is her inheritance.

—

## The Selfie as Artifact

There is something worth pausing on about the specific mechanism that broke the case: a selfie.

Selfies — self-portraits taken with the front-facing camera of a smartphone — became ubiquitous around 2013 and 2014, as smartphones with capable front cameras became common. By January 2015, they were a standard part of how teenagers documented their social lives and shared them with networks of family and friends.

If the encounter between Cassidy and Miché had happened five years earlier, the selfie mechanism might not have been available in the same form. The documentation of the resemblance might have required a different kind of image — a formal photo, or a description, or someone physically bringing Morne to see the girl. The selfie allowed the visual comparison to travel instantly to Morne and Celeste, with the kind of detail and angle that made the resemblance unmistakable.

ADVERTISEMENT
Advertisement
Share.