The long-term development of Miché’s relationships with her biological family is a continuing process. The documentary, the book, the publicly shared milestones — Celeste and Morne’s remarriage, the grandchildren — suggest that those relationships have developed in real ways. They are not resolved in the sense of being complete. Human relationships rarely are.

The larger question the case raises — about identity, about the difference between biological family and formed family, about what a person owes to both — is not the kind of question that resolves. It is the kind of question that is lived with.

—

## The Judge’s Reckoning

When Judge President John Hlophe sentenced Lavona Solomon in August 2016, he addressed the nature of the offense in terms that the law required him to use: premeditated, serious, deserving of custodial punishment. He rejected the defense’s plea for leniency based on Solomon’s health and status as a first-time offender.

The effective sentence — ten years, with four suspended — was at the lower end of what the state had sought. Prosecutors had argued for fifteen years. The judge’s calculation appears to have balanced the seriousness of the offense against the specific circumstances of the offender: a woman in her fifties, in poor health, with no prior criminal record.

The Nurse family, testifying at sentencing, described a relationship with their daughter that was essentially nonexistent. This was the specific harm they could articulate for the court: not only the loss of seventeen years, but the ongoing loss of the relationship itself. Having found Zephany, they had not thereby recovered what had been taken from them. The girl who came back was not the daughter they had lost — not because she was not their biological child, but because she had grown up without them, had formed herself in a different world, and did not know them or owe them the relationship they had been building in imagination for seventeen years.

ADVERTISEMENT
Advertisement
Share.