This impersonality makes the crime in some ways more disturbing than a targeted abduction. The infant taken was not specially chosen. The family left devastated was not specially targeted. The randomness was part of the horror.

Celeste also said she wanted to thank Lavona for looking after her daughter. This is an extraordinary thing for the mother of a kidnapped child to say, and it was widely remarked on in the media coverage. It reflects a coherent position: Lavona’s crime against the Nurse family was real and serious; Lavona’s care of the child she took was also real. These two facts do not cancel each other out.

Morne’s role throughout the case — the sustained search, the recognition of the selfie, the engagement with police — represents a father’s sustained refusal to accept that the case was over. The annual birthday appeals were his initiative as much as Celeste’s. The final recognition of the selfie that broke the case was his.

After the discovery, Morne’s relationship with Miché was harder than Celeste’s, by some accounts. Miché’s memoir reportedly described him critically. His public response to the memoir was silence — a choice not to publicly engage with his daughter’s account of him.

Both Morne and Celeste demonstrated a consistent commitment to remaining available to Miché without insisting on a relationship she was not ready to have. Celeste’s statement — “as long as I know where my child is, I’m OK” — is a statement of a parent who has recalibrated her expectations to fit a reality that did not match what she had searched for.

ADVERTISEMENT
Advertisement
Share.