The prosecution’s account differed fundamentally. The prosecution held that Lavona Solomon had herself entered Groote Schuur Hospital on April 30, 1997, using a nurse’s appearance to gain access to the maternity ward, and had taken Zephany directly from the cot beside Celeste’s bed.

Shireen Piet testified that Lavona had previously attempted to take a baby from the same ward — that she had seen the accused trying to take a baby into a lift on a prior visit to the hospital. This testimony directly contradicted the account of an innocent woman tricked into receiving a baby. No evidence was ever found that a woman named “Sylvia” existed.

—

## Guilty

On March 10, 2016, the Western Cape High Court found Lavona Solomon guilty of kidnapping, fraud, and contravening sections of the Children’s Act.

The verdict followed weeks of testimony. The judge, addressing the evidence, found it overwhelming against the accused. Lavona’s account of the mysterious Sylvia and the handoff at a train station found no corroboration. The birth registration she had filed in 2003 — presenting Miché as her and Michael’s biological child — constituted the fraud charge. The violations of the Children’s Act related to the fraudulent registration and the circumstances of the child’s upbringing under a false identity.

Lavona Solomon, convicted on all counts, faced sentencing later that year.

—

## The Girl in the Middle

As the legal proceedings advanced, Miché was at the center of competing pressures that she did not ask for and could not control. She was seventeen — later eighteen — years old. The adults around her had sharply defined positions: her biological family wanted her home, the woman who raised her was on trial, the courts were making decisions about her welfare, the media had descended on the story.

ADVERTISEMENT
Advertisement
Share.