This meant that even if the Fort Worth Police Department were to identify and locate the woman who had taken Melissa in 1971, no prosecution for the original abduction would be possible. The window for justice in the criminal sense had closed years before the family ever found their daughter.
Jeff Highsmith was vocal about his frustration. He and his family called for changes to the statute of limitations laws, arguing that fifty-one years had been stolen from them and that the law as written effectively protected kidnappers who managed to stay hidden long enough.
When the police formally confirmed Melissa’s identity through official DNA testing in May 2023, the Fort Worth Police Department issued a statement through its Major Case Unit. DNA testing, they said, had confirmed that Melanie Brown — one of the names Melissa had used as an adult — was Melissa Highsmith. They noted they hoped the confirmation would offer additional closure to the family. They asked anyone with information about the original 1971 abduction to come forward.
The case remained open. Not in terms of prosecution — that possibility had closed years earlier — but in terms of the full record. The name and identity of the woman who had answered Alta Apantenco’s babysitting advertisement in 1971, taken her twenty-two-month-old daughter, and disappeared, remained unknown to authorities.
The investigation, the department said, would continue.
—
## What Official Confirmation Means
The gap between November 2022 and May 2023 — between the family’s private certainty and the police department’s official confirmation — matters more than it might initially appear.
