What is known about the woman who raised Melissa comes largely from what Melissa herself disclosed publicly. The woman told Melissa, through a Facebook contact after the DNA match, that she had bought her “off the street” in 1972 for five hundred dollars — framing herself as a purchaser rather than the original kidnapper.
Melissa doubted this account. She told People magazine that she believed the woman who raised her was the same person who had answered the babysitting advertisement and taken her. The “$500 off the street” story, in Melissa’s view, was an attempt to distance herself from the original crime.
This is an important distinction that the available evidence cannot resolve. It is entirely possible that two separate women were involved — one who took Melissa from her family, and another who purchased or received her and raised her. It is also possible that the woman who raised Melissa was the original kidnapper. Without a successful criminal investigation or a confession that investigators can verify, the full sequence of events between August 23, 1971, and whenever Melissa came to be with the woman who raised her remains unclear.
What is not in dispute is that the woman who raised her knew, by her own admission, that she was raising someone else’s child. She said she had known. She said she had always wanted to tell Melissa. She said, in that Facebook message, that she had been waiting to unburden herself of the knowledge.
Whether that knowledge makes her complicit in the original abduction, or a secondary figure who received a stolen child, is a legal and moral question that the expired statute of limitations means will likely never be formally adjudicated.
