Three weeks from match to contact. Three weeks from contact to a family that had been torn apart in 1971 sitting together again in 2022.

—

## What the Search Cost Alta

Alta Apantenco has been a relatively quiet presence in the public reporting on this case, which is fitting. She is, in many ways, the person at the center of the original wound.

She was twenty-two years old when her daughter was taken. She was a single mother working as a waitress who needed help and placed a newspaper advertisement for a babysitter. The act of placing that advertisement has sometimes been referenced in ways that imply criticism — the suggestion being that a more careful parent would not have handed her child to a stranger.

That implication is worth examining and rejecting. Single mothers in 1971 faced different circumstances than parents today. Formal childcare infrastructure was limited. Background checks were not widely available. Placing a newspaper advertisement for a babysitter was a normal and common practice. The crime that occurred was the fault of the person who answered the advertisement with the intention of taking the child — not the fault of a young mother who needed help.

What Alta lived through in the fifty-one years between losing Melissa and finding her can only be guessed at. She wrote a public letter two weeks after the abduction that described going out of her mind with worry. She went on to have more children. She never stopped being Melissa’s mother.

When police in 1971 ran out of leads and effectively closed the active investigation, there were reports that investigators had at some point wondered whether something other than abduction had occurred — whether Alta herself might have harmed Melissa. Such suspicion is not unusual in missing child cases, where statistics show that in many cases involving young children, family members are responsible. But no evidence supported any such conclusion in the Highsmith case. Alta’s behavior — the advertisement, the immediate call to police, the public letter, the decades of searching — was consistent with a mother who had lost a child to a stranger and never stopped trying to get her back.

ADVERTISEMENT
Advertisement
Share.