It was the kind of case that left a family shattered and a community with no answers. In 1971, the tools available to investigators were limited: no national DNA database, no digital records network, no genetic genealogy. If you didn’t find a missing child quickly, the trail went cold in ways that could last decades.
For the Highsmith family, it lasted fifty-one years.
—
## “I Beg of You to Call Me”
Alta Apantenco did not go quietly.
Two weeks after Melissa disappeared, on September 8, 1971, the Fort Worth Star-Telegram ran a letter on its front page under a photograph of Alta. It was addressed to whoever had taken her daughter.
She wrote that she had been going out of her mind with worry. She said the kidnapper had not called, and that she was begging her to make contact. She offered to forget about the kidnapping entirely if Melissa were returned. She said the baby could be sent back without anyone knowing. She wanted only one thing.
“I beg of you to call me.”
No one called.
Alta went on to have more children. Life moved forward in the relentless way that life does even after catastrophe. But the absence of Melissa never closed. It sat at the center of the family like a wound that could not fully heal, reopened every time someone asked about the missing daughter, every time another year passed without news, every time investigators had nothing new to report.
The Fort Worth police periodically returned to the case. Over the following decades, investigators revisited the file, but the trail remained cold. The woman who had called herself the babysitter had given a false name — investigators came to believe “Ruth Johnson” was an alias — and there was no way to find her.
