For fifty-one years, the woman who would eventually reclaim the name Melissa Highsmith understood herself to be Melanie. She did not know what her last name at birth was. She did not know that another family existed who thought of her as theirs, who marked her birthday every November, who kept baby photographs in a folder and updated a Facebook page and refused to stop looking.

She did not know any of this because she had no reason to look. The woman who raised her had given her a name and an identity, and that was the identity she lived. It was not a happy childhood — she has said as much publicly — but unhappy childhoods are not unusual, and they do not, by themselves, suggest to a person that they were stolen.

The question of what it means to grow up without your true identity is one that adoptees, donor-conceived individuals, and others with complex family origins have written about extensively. The experience of discovering a discontinuity at the foundation of your sense of self is disorienting in ways that are difficult to describe to those who haven’t lived it. The landmarks you thought were fixed turn out to be movable. The story you thought you were living turns out to have a different beginning.

For Melissa, the discontinuity was total. She was not an adoptee who knew she had been placed with a family. She was not a donor-conceived person who understood that her origins were complicated. She believed — had every reason to believe — that the woman who raised her was her mother. She believed her name was Melanie. She believed her history was what she had been told.

ADVERTISEMENT
Advertisement
Share.