The parallel effort — submitting DNA to consumer testing databases — was equally strategic. Jeff’s parents submitted their DNA. The database grew. And they waited.

The waiting had a specific character to it, different from the waiting of the early decades. In the 1970s and 1980s, waiting for Melissa to be found meant waiting for a lead, a witness, a confession, or a miracle. By 2018, waiting meant watching a database grow. It meant knowing that somewhere in the world, a biological relative of Melissa’s might submit their DNA — a cousin, a sibling, a child — and that when they did, the algorithm would flag it.

It was a more patient kind of hope. Not passive — the page was active, the family engaged — but slower. Waiting for the database to become large enough to find what they were looking for.

—

## How Genealogical DNA Investigations Work

The technique used to find Melissa Highsmith sits at the intersection of consumer genetics and investigative genealogy. Understanding it in some detail helps explain both how powerful it has become and what its limitations are.

Consumer genetic testing platforms like 23andMe and Ancestry.com work by sequencing what are called autosomal DNA markers — specific locations on the chromosomes inherited from both parents, spread across the genome. When two people share a certain number of these markers, the platform flags them as likely relatives and estimates the probable relationship based on how much DNA they share.

The key unit of measurement is the centimorgan. A centimorgan (abbreviated cM) is a unit of genetic length that corresponds to a 1 percent probability that a recombination (a crossing-over of chromosomes during reproduction) will occur in a single generation. In practice, the centimorgan is used to measure how much DNA two people share.

ADVERTISEMENT
Advertisement
Share.