For Alta Apantenco, the question involves something additional: the question of how much of her life has been shaped by guilt, however unwarranted. She placed a newspaper advertisement. She left her child with a roommate who handed the baby to a stranger. She woke up and her daughter was gone.

None of that makes her responsible for what happened. The responsibility lies entirely with the person who chose to take a child. But the irrational weight of “if only” — the impossible counterfactuals, the moments that could have gone differently if any small thing had been different — tends to settle on the person who was present, whether or not they did anything wrong.

Whatever Alta has carried for fifty-one years on that front is her own to disclose or not disclose. What is public is that she did everything a person could do after the fact: she called the police immediately, she made public pleas, she wrote a front-page letter, she kept searching, she submitted her DNA.

And when her daughter was found, she said it was the best day of her life.

That statement, brief as it is, says something about how the reunion reorganized what had come before. Not erasing it. Not making the fifty-one years irrelevant. But changing the shape of the story — from a tragedy without resolution to a tragedy that eventually, improbably, found its way to something like peace.

—

## What “Resolution” Can Mean

The word “resolution” is often applied to cases like Melissa Highsmith’s — cases where a missing person is found, where the question of what happened to them is answered, where the family can finally know.

ADVERTISEMENT
Advertisement
Share.