But from the perspective of families searching for missing persons, the growth of the databases is unambiguously significant. Every new kit submitted is a potential connection. Every year the databases grow, the web becomes denser and more capable of capturing the connections that cold cases need.
For the families who are still waiting, the database is not just a technology. It is a form of hope.
—
## A Community That Helped
The Melissa Highsmith case did not happen in isolation. It unfolded within a broader community of people who care about missing persons cases — advocates, genealogists, journalists, cold case podcasters, true crime researchers, and ordinary people who follow cases and share information.
That community is not always helpful. True crime attention can sometimes intrude on families at their most vulnerable, can generate speculation that is not grounded in evidence, can create pressure on investigators or on families themselves. The ethics of true crime engagement are genuinely complicated, and the Highsmith case was not immune to those complications.
But the community also played a role in keeping the case alive. The national coverage generated by the NCMEC age-progression release in September 2022 — coverage that reached millions of people through social media shares, true crime accounts, and general news distribution — put the case in front of an audience that might include the person who eventually took the right action.
The Charleston tip came from that audience. It was wrong. But it generated further coverage, which may have contributed to whatever sequence of events led to the DNA connection being identified in the weeks that followed.
