The Highsmith family traveled to Charleston. They searched. They asked questions. Fort Worth Police Sergeant Amelia Heise said her department would investigate the tip and asked the public for information.
The Charleston lead didn’t pan out.
Melissa Highsmith was not in South Carolina. She had never been in South Carolina. She was in Fort Worth, Texas — the same city where she had been taken as a toddler, the same city where her family had lived for fifty years, in some accounts living only about ten minutes from where the Highsmith family resided.
But the national publicity generated by the NCMEC age-progression image and the Charleston tip did something else. It put the Highsmith case in front of millions of people at the same time that the genetic databases were more populated than they had ever been.
—
## How DNA Finds the Missing
Consumer genetic testing works on a principle that seems almost too simple: DNA is shared between biological relatives, and the closer the relationship, the more DNA is shared.
When someone submits a saliva sample to 23andMe or Ancestry.com, their genetic material is processed and compared algorithmically against every other profile in the database. The platform identifies long stretches of matching DNA — segments that appear identical between two samples, suggesting a shared ancestor — and uses those to estimate the probable relationship.
A parent and child typically share about 50 percent of their DNA. Grandparents and grandchildren share about 25 percent. First cousins share about 12.5 percent. Second cousins share roughly 3 percent. The more DNA two people share, the closer their relationship is likely to be.
