What is recorded is what Alta saw, what the roommate reported, what the police investigated, and what Melissa has shared about her own experience and the message she received. That is enough to understand the broad shape of what happened. It is not enough to know the full story.
Whether the full story will ever be told is an open question.
—
## Genetic Genealogy and the Future of Cold Cases
The identification of Melissa Highsmith through 23andMe is one of a growing number of cases in which consumer genetic databases have been used to solve cold cases that conventional investigation could not crack.
The technique first gained widespread public attention with the identification of the Golden State Killer in April 2018. Joseph James DeAngelo, a former California police officer suspected of multiple murders and sexual assaults in the 1970s and 1980s, was identified through forensic genetic genealogy — a process in which investigators uploaded DNA from crime scene evidence to GEDmatch, a public genealogy database, then worked backward through family trees to identify him as the likely suspect.
The success of that case demonstrated what many genealogists and investigators had believed for years: that the combination of large consumer databases, genealogical expertise, and public records could solve crimes that had resisted conventional investigation for decades.
In the years since, the technique has been applied to dozens of cases. Unidentified remains have been given names. Cold case murders have been solved. The legal and ethical frameworks governing the use of genetic genealogy for law enforcement purposes have evolved, with varying approaches in different states.
