They submitted DNA to 23andMe — presumably for the same reasons most people do. They were curious about their ancestry. They wanted to know more about their genetic background. They filled out the forms, provided their saliva samples, and waited for results.

What came back was the genetic record of their family — including, on their mother’s side, connections to a grandfather who had been searching for their mother for decades.

They did not know that grandfather existed. They did not know their mother had a biological family that had been looking for her. They certainly did not know that their personal genetic information would become the instrument of a reunion that would rewrite their family’s history.

This aspect of the case raises questions that are genuinely interesting from an ethical and legal standpoint. Can a person’s DNA reveal information about family members who did not consent to its disclosure? In this case, the answer turns out to be yes — Melissa’s identity was effectively revealed through her children’s DNA, which identified her as the mother of people who shared Jeffrie Highsmith’s genetic signature.

Melissa was not in the database. But her children were. And their presence in the database was sufficient to identify her.

This is not a criticism of the outcome — the outcome was a family reunited after fifty-one years, and that is an unambiguous good. But it is a dimension of consumer DNA testing that is worth understanding: when you submit your DNA to a database, you are not only providing information about yourself. You are providing information about your biological relatives, including relatives who have not consented to being identified.

ADVERTISEMENT
Advertisement
Share.