These remaining questions are not deficiencies in the story. They are part of what it means for a case to be real rather than resolved on a television timeline. Real cases leave threads. Real people contain more than what they choose to share with journalists. Real resolutions are partial and ongoing.

The Melissa Highsmith case has a resolution. It also has a present tense. The people in it are still living their lives, still working out what this discovery means, still building something new from what was found.

That is not a disappointing ending. It is an honest one.

—

## Closing: The Database and the Family

There is a version of the Melissa Highsmith story in which the technology is the protagonist. In that version, 23andMe’s algorithm is the hero. The centimorgans are the instrument of discovery. The database is what did it.

That version is true, as far as it goes.

But there is another version in which the technology is merely the latest tool deployed by people who refused to stop. In that version, the protagonist is Alta Apantenco, writing a letter on the front page of a newspaper in 1971, begging a kidnapper to call. The protagonist is Jeff Highsmith, building a Facebook page in 2018 when most people would have given up decades before. The protagonist is the family that submitted DNA to databases not knowing if the connection they needed would ever be in those databases.

The technology gave them a way to do what they had always been trying to do. Without the family, the technology would have produced a match that no one knew how to interpret. Without the technology, the family’s determination would have produced continued, frustrated searching.

ADVERTISEMENT
Advertisement
Share.